Pages

Tuesday, January 25, 2011

Supreme Court on Renting On 24th January - Service Tax

---------- Forwarded message ----------
From: Rebecca Andrews <rebecca.andrews88@yahoo.in>
Date: Sun, Jan 23, 2011 at 9:23 PM
Subject: {jalgaoncas} Supreme Court on Renting On 24th January - Service Tax
To:


My senior Mr. Rakesh Chitkara, Advocate, Delhi High Court has forwarded the following text :


Supreme Court will hear a clutch of petitions on service tax on renting where the plea will be made to restore the stay granted to Home Solutions by Delhi High Court (DHC) and vacated by SC on 10th Jan. 


Hearing is of the SLP filed by the Govt. against the orders pronounced by DHC in 2009 holding that renting is not a service, per se. SC has yet to hear the main petition and pronounce its judgement. 


As per the statistics of the CBEC, nearly 70,000 crores is riding on this dispute. Delhi High Court is scheduled to hear the main petition the next day, i.e. on 25th January, 2011.


It has been a conscious decision for our clients not to take their matter to the Supreme Court as yet, and burden them with additional costs. 

SUPREME COURT OF INDIA

Daily Cause List

( For 24th, January, 2011 )

 

                                      COURT NO. 13

                         HON'BLE DR. JUSTICE MUKUNDAKAM SHARMA

                         HON'BLE MR. JUSTICE ANIL R. DAVE

                         --------------------------------

                         PART-A     MISCELLANEOUS MATTERS

                         --------------------------------

          I.A.,CMPS,CRLMPS ETC.

          ---------------------

 


          -----------------------------------------

 

2.  SLP(C)No.13850/2009 UNION OF INDIA & ORS.           MR. ARVIND KUMAR SHARMA

       III  A/N-H         Vs. HOME SOLUTION RETAIL INDIA     MR. E.C. AGRAWALA

      S.( 431)(29/05/2009)    LTD. & ORS.                    MS. N.ANNAPOORANI

                              (WITH APPLN.(S) FOR EXEMPTION FROM

       2ND LISTING             FILING C/C OF THE IMPUGNED

                               JUDGMENT AND WITH PRAYER FOR

                               INTERIM RELIEF)

      WITH

           T.P.(C)No.686-707/2009 UNION OF INDIA             MR. SHREEKANT N. TERDAL

       XVIA A/N-H         Vs. A.P.SELVARAJAN & ORS.          MS. SHIRIN KHAJURIA

      S.(1801)(28/07/2009)    (WITH APPLN.(S) FOR STAY AND        MR. E.C. AGRAWALA

       2ND LISTING             VACATING STAY)                     MR. PRAVEEN KUMAR

          MR. SUBRAMONIUM PRASAD, MR. R. PRAKASH, M/S. M.V. KINI & ASSOCIATES,

           SLP(C)No.36137-36158/2009 UNION OF INDIA & ORS.   MR. B. KRISHNA PRASAD

       III  A/N-O         Vs. M/S LIFESTYLE INTERNATIONAL P. M/S. O.P. KHAITAN  CO

      S.( 431)(09/12/2009)    LTD.&ORS.                      MR. SANJAY JAIN

                              (WITH APPLN.(S) FOR EXEMPTION FROM  MS.JYOTI MENDIRATTA

       2ND LISTING             FILING C/C OF THE IMPUGNED         MR.CHIRAG M.SHROFF

                               JUDGMENT AND OFFICE REPORT)

           SLP(C)No.36269/2009 UNION OF INDIA & ORS.         MR. B. KRISHNA PRASAD

       III  A/N-O         Vs. M/S MADHUR IMPEX & ORS.

      S.( 431)(07/12/2009)    (WITH PRAYER FOR INTERIM RELIEF)

       2ND LISTING

           SLP(C)No.36270/2009 UNION OF INDIA & ANR.         MR. B. KRISHNA PRASAD

       III  A/N-O         Vs. DIVYA KALRA

      S.( 431)(14/12/2009)    (WITH PRAYER FOR INTERIM RELIEF)

       2ND LISTING

           SLP(C)No.2460/2010 UNION OF INDIA & ORS.          MR. B. KRISHNA PRASAD

       III  A/N-O         Vs. BAJAJ JEWELS(I) P.LTD.& ORS.

      S.( 431)(02/01/2010)    (WITH PRAYER FOR INTERIM RELIEF)

       2ND LISTING

           SLP(C)No.4685/2010 UNION OF INDIA & ORS.          MR. B. KRISHNA PRASAD

       III  A/N-O         Vs. HARIKIRAT SODHI

      S.( 431)(20/01/2010)    (WITH APPLN.(S) FOR PERMISSION TO   MR. SANJAY SHARAWAT

       2ND LISTING             FILE AFFIDAVIT AND WITH PRAYER

                               FOR INTERIM RELIEF)

           SLP(C)No.4316-4323/2010 UNION OF INDIA & ORS.     MR. B. KRISHNA PRASAD

       III  A/N-O         Vs. JANAK PLACE MARKET ASSN.& ORS. M/S. O.P. KHAITAN  CO

      S.( 431)(17/12/2009)    (WITH APPLN.(S) FOR EXEMPTION FROM

       2ND LISTING             FILING C/C OF THE IMPUGNED

                               JUDGMENT AND WITH PRAYER FOR

                               INTERIM RELIEF)

           C.A.No.4486/2010 UNION OF INDIA & ORS.            MR. B. KRISHNA PRASAD

       III                Vs. UTV SOFTWARE COMMUNICATIONS    MR. ANKUR MITTAL

      S.( 431)                LTD.

                              (WITH OFFICE REPORT)

       1ST LISTING

           C.A.No.4487/2010 UNION OF INDIA AND ORS.          MR. B. KRISHNA PRASAD

       III                Vs. UTV NEWS LTD.                  MR. ANKUR MITTAL

      S.( 431)                (WITH OFFICE REPORT)

       1ST LISTING

           SLP(C)No.26373/2010 UNION OF INDIA & ORS.         MRS ANIL KATIYAR

       III  A/N-O         Vs. DEVYANI INTERNATIONAL LTD.&

      S.( 431)(26/08/2010)    ORS.

                              (WITH APPLN.(S) FOR C/DELAY IN

       2ND LISTING             FILING SLP AND C/DELAY IN

                               REFILING SLP AND OFFICE REPORT)

           SLP(C)No.31324/2010 UNION OF INDIA                MR. B. KRISHNA PRASAD

       III  A/N-O         Vs. M/S FLAMINGO DUTY SHOPS PVT.   M/S. M.V. KINI & ASSOCIATES

      S.( 431)(07/10/2010)    LTD & ANR.                     M/S SURESH A. SHROFF & CO

                              (WITH APPLN.(S) FOR C/DELAY IN

       2ND LISTING             FILING SLP AND EXEMPTION FROM

                               FILING C/C OF THE IMPUGNED ORDER

                               AND OFFICE REPORT)

           T.P.(C)No.236/2007 AIRPORTS AUTHORITY OF INDIA    M/S. M.V. KINI & ASSOCIATES

       XVIA A/N-H             ETC. Vs. M/S FELMINGO DUTY     M/S GAGRAT & CO

      S.(1801)(05/04/2007)    FREE SHOPS P.LTD.& ANR         MR. B. KRISHNA PRASAD

                              (WITH APPLN.(S) FOR DIRECTIONS AND  M/S SURESH A. SHROFF & CO

       5TH LISTING             STAY AND OFFICE REPORT)            MR. V. BALACHANDRAN

          MRS LALITA KAUSHIK, MR. ABHIJAT P. MEDH, MR. M.A.CHINNASAMY,

          MR. SANJAY R. HEGDE, MS. KAVITA WADIA,

            T.P.(C)No.630-641/2007                           M/S. M.V. KINI & ASSOCIATES

       XVIA A/N-H             AIRPORTS AUTHORITY OF INDIA & M/S. PAREKH & CO

      S.(1801)(29/08/2007)    ORS. Vs. M/S HIGGINBOTHAMS     MR. B. KRISHNA PRASAD

       2ND LISTING            PVT.LTD.& ORS.                 MS. KAVITA WADIA

                              (WITH APPLN.(S) FOR DIRECTIONS AND  MR.M.P.DEVANATH

                               STAY AND OFFICE REPORT)

           T.P.(C)No.54-57/2008 AIRPORT AUTHORITY OF INDIA   M/S. M.V. KINI & ASSOCIATES

       XVIA A/N-H         Vs. MD.AKHTAR HUSSAIN KHAN & ORS.  MR. BIJOY KUMAR JAIN

      S.(1801)(16/01/2008)    (WITH APPLN.(S) FOR SUBSTITUTED     MR. DHARAM BIR RAJ VOHRA

       2ND LISTING             SERVICE AND STAY)                  MR. B.V. BALARAM DAS

           T.P.(C)No.451/2010 AIRPORT DIR.AIRPORT AUTH.OF    M/S. M.V. KINI & ASSOCIATES

       XVIA A/N-H             INDIA & ANR                    M/S. T.T.K. DEEPAK & CO

      S.(1802)(30/04/2010)Vs. C.SADANANDAN & ORS.

                              (WITH OFFICE REPORT)

       2ND LISTING

           T.P.(C)No.807-821/2008 UNION OF INDIA & ORS.      MR. B.V. BALARAM DAS

       XVIA A/N-H         Vs. RETAILERS ASSOCIACTION OF      MR. E.C. AGRAWALA

      S.(1801)(04/08/2008)    INDIA & ORS.                   MR. DINESH KUMAR GARG

                              (WITH APPLN.(S) FOR STAY)           MR. E.C. AGRAWALA

       2ND LISTING

          MR. RAJAN NARAIN, MR. NIKHIL NAYYAR, MS. LIZ MATHEW, MR. R.CHANDRACHUD,

           SLP(C)No.9013/2007 AJAY PAL REDDY                 MR. BIJOY KUMAR JAIN

       III  A/N-H         Vs. AIRPORT AUTHORITY OF INDIA &   M/S. M.V. KINI & ASSOCIATES

      S.( 431)(11/05/2007)    ORS.                           MR. B. KRISHNA PRASAD

                              (WITH PRAYER FOR INTERIM RELIEF

       5TH LISTING             AND OFFICE REPORT)

           T.P.(C)No.738-796/2009 UNION OF INDIA & ORS.      MRS ANIL KATIYAR

       XVIA A/N-H         Vs. G.S.G.BUILDERS & INFRASTR.LTD. M/S. KHAITAN & CO

      S.(1802)(04/08/2009)    & ORS.                         MR. E.C. AGRAWALA

                              (WITH APPLN.(S) FOR STAY AND        MR. M.P. JHA

       2ND LISTING             OFFICE REPORT)                     MR. ANIL KUMAR TANDALE

          MR. Y. RAJA GOPALA RAO, M/S. K.J. JOHN & CO, MR. SANJAY JAIN,

          MS. KAVITA WADIA, M/S.MAHALAKSHMI BALAJI & CO, MR. G.N.REDDY,

          MR. ANIL KUMAR MISHRA,

           W.P.(C)No.147/2009 RAKESH MAHAJAN                 MR. M.A.CHINNASAMY

       X    ADJD-H        Vs. UNION OF INDIA & ORS.

      S.( 431)(02/04/2009)    (WITH APPLN.(S) FOR INTERIM RELIEF

       2ND LISTING             AND PERMISSION TO FILE ADDITIONAL

                               DOCUMENTS AND OFFICE REPORT)

 

Kind regards,

Rebecca Andrews

No comments:

Post a Comment