Fwd: dice are thrown; odds in whose favour - probability of VP of ICAI - from Western India Regional Council

---------- Forwarded message ----------

From: Suneel Appaji FCA <appaji@appaji.com>
Date: Wed, Jan 30, 2013 at 12:27 PM
Subject: dice are thrown; odds in whose favour - probability of VP of ICAI - from Western India Regional Council
To:


Dear All

I have collected opinions from various quarters and submitting my analysis to you without bias

• Out of 11 candidates from west,  5 are new faces and thus am excluding them
• Out of balance 6, 3 are in 2nd term and 3 are in final term.
• Adukia,  Sanjeev Maheshwari & Pankaj Jain are in final term / Nilesh, Dhinal & Zaware are in Second term
• It is expected that all the 6 will try their luck

Pankaj Jain

• Am told, he is too frank, too straight forward and too blunt
• How can I expect the political personalities vote to such a person and therefore feel he may not get elected to VP position
• However, he has a chance if second, third preferences are in his favour and in fray till those are counted, subject to my comments elsewhere

Nilesh

• Is a Gujarati - if anti Marwadi forces join hands, this factor helps
• Is related to previous President, Kamlesh
• Is considered to be in the team opposite of Subodh
• Is part of MAFIA and thus other MAFIA'ns should support
• Non controversial
• Unlike most of the other Council members is an expert in Accountants & audit - am sure this can be added advantage because in politics subject knowledge is never a factor
• Am told believes in process in every matter - when the Council is known for violation of every process, even this factor is negative for the voters

Dhinal

• Is from MAFIA - one of the Big Four
• Is a Gujarati
• Tech savoy

Zaware

• Am sure, is the senior most in age
• Prefers to be in the Council for 1 more term, to protect his business interests
• may contest for namesake

Sanjeev Maheshwari

• Close to Subodh
• Non-controversial
• Acceptable to most of the voters
• He is a Marwadi 
• You will generally here from him - "there are 2 sides of a coin" 
• Many analysts are zeroing on this man

Adukia

• Senior most Council member
• Shares Knowledge with members ( few critics say not his own knowledge but even if the knowledge is not his original, after all he shares is a great virtue is my answer)
• In ICAI politics from 1992, if my memory is right i.e spent more than 2/3 of his professional life as elected member in RC & CC
• Is a Marwadi and that too Agarwal. In the newly constituted Council, if these factors work, he should get quota at the first count itself - adukiaji please insist for open counting and declaring the transfer of votes etc
• Most of the members in Hyderabad told me they will give first preference to Adukia and second to me in the just concluded central council elections.....am sure he can get elected to Council by contesting from any of the regions
•  Finally, if not made President in this term, will come back to Council after a gap is worry of many Council members & Council aspirants is why they want Adukia to be President in this term so that in his life he will not come to Council again

 

Note:  - Our JV,  from South, that too from Hyderabad may kill aspirations & chances of these above persons is my gut feeling as JV is desperate in becoming VP this year and JV's aspirations and chances are in the hands of Devanna & Babu

The above opinions are collected from various members and put in at one place by me

Will email about other regions,after collecting data & info

--
Suneel Kumar Appaji FCA

Knowledge Architect & Management Adviser

99893 10302, 90147 10302